Spiral pattern made from repeated images of US 100 dollar bills with Benjamin Franklin's portrait.

The Market is Sending a Message

Solidarity Sunday: The Market is Sending a Message

11/01/2026

A skilled tradesperson's work isn't limited to one industry. Electricians, pipefitters, welders, millwrights, boilermakers, instrument technicians, and other skilled workers can bring their experience to refineries, chemical plants, power plants, data centers, and other major projects. These industries often draw from the same pool of skilled people.

Some industrial work comes in concentrated bursts. Refineries and chemical plants schedule turnarounds, planned shutdowns when crews inspect, repair, and overhaul equipment. Power plants schedule outages or shutdowns to do similar work on generating units. Electricians and members of other trades are essential to maintaining these facilities and safely returning them to service. The work is demanding and often runs on a tight schedule. When a project ends, workers may face uncertainty about what comes next.

Data center construction can offer a different opportunity, a longer stretch of work on a major project. Electricians are central to building and powering these facilities, and other trades are needed throughout construction. If the pay is competitive and the schedule is more predictable, it's understandable that skilled workers may choose that opportunity over a job with long hours and gaps between calls.

But competition for skilled workers is not only about which industry offers the best opportunity. Rules set by owners and contractors can affect who is allowed to take a job, and whether a contractor can respond to a shortage by offering better pay.

In one local union, a power company subcontracted electrical work that was difficult to fill. The subcontractor was prepared to offer above scale pay and a per diem. Yet the power company would not allow local workers to receive the higher rate, explaining that it did not want them to leave their current jobs for the new call. Instead, travelers from other jurisdictions were allowed to take the work at the higher compensation.

That left the business manager with a difficult choice. Should he run the call without telling local members that travelers doing the same work could earn more? Or should he tell local hands plainly that they would be paid less than travelers on the same job? Either choice put him in a difficult position, created by a policy that limited local members' access to the higher paying call.

If the work needed people, and local hands were willing to take it, why prevent them from responding to the offer? The stated concern was keeping crews in place at other facilities. But the effect was to restrict local workers' choices while bringing in travelers who also had to leave their own jobs, travel, and spend time away from their families.

This is the kind of situation local union leaders across the building trades need to understand and examine. When a contractor says a job is hard to staff, ask what is preventing the job from being filled. Are the wages competitive? Can the contractor offer a premium or per diem? Are owner policies or agreements restricting who can take the call? And what happens to staffing at the other facilities when workers move?

Pay rates matter, but so do the hours, the length of the call, the time between jobs, travel demands, and whether a worker can count on being dispatched again. Members compare the whole experience, not just the hourly rate on a job posting. Business managers can track where members are going, what calls they are turning down, and what they say would make a job workable.

Workers have every right to choose the job that best fits their family, finances, and future. Building trades unions also have a responsibility to understand how industries compete for skilled people, and how company policies can shape that competition.

Turnaround and outage work demand skill, judgment, endurance, and teamwork from people in many trades. The compensation and working conditions have to reflect those demands if companies expect to retain the experienced workers who know how to do the work well. And when a contractor is ready to offer more to fill a call, local leaders should know whether the owner is allowing that response, or preventing it.

The question isn't whether experienced tradespeople are valuable. The question is whether the market is treating them that way.

When skilled workers find steadier or better paying work elsewhere, the industry should pay attention. When local workers are prevented from taking a job that needs to be filled, the industry should pay attention to that, too.

Because eventually every industry has to answer a simple question: Who is going to do the work?